TJG: Next Gen NYC S2 Reunion Part 1!

Two Judgey Girls

Mary and Courtney from Two Judgey Girls dive into Part 1 of the Next Gen NYC reunion, dissecting character dynamics, relationship updates, a

Key takeaways

• The hosts admit to being wrong about Leigh Boyfriend's presence at Burning Man, acknowledging a strategic social media move by Bethany.
• Haley from New York is revealed to be significantly younger than previously guessed—54 was an incorrect estimate, sparking playful backlash and self-correction.

Main topics

• Next Gen NYC Reunion Part 1 Recap
• Fan Theories and Misconceptions Corrected

Notable quotes

"I was wrong. I want to take that back." – Mary admitting error about Leigh Boyfriend's Burning Man trip.

Conclusion

The hosts wrap Part 1 with playful honesty, correcting past mistakes,

Transcript preview

Speaker 1 (0:02) you Speaker 1 (0:15) Welcome back to Two Judgy Girls. This is Mary from the Bay. And it's Courtney from L.A. And it is a day of the week right now. Well, you're not in L.A. That is true. I am not in L.A. I am currently in Scottsdale visiting my fam. And let me just tell you what a large house is compared to like my house. When I say large, I mean full of people. My normal day is I wake up between 630 and 7. I sit in silence for most of my morning until I'm chit-chatting with you. I wake up, I have a coffee, I watch the show that we're going to talk about, I get myself ready. You have a very Speaker 2 (0:56) lovely Speaker 1 (0:56) morning. But when I'm here, it's like everyone's, they're up at 5 a.m. Now, they're not waking me up at 5 a.m., but by the time I have done my work and I'm going to go get my coffee, everybody's up. Speaker 2 (1:07) Who wakes up at 5 a.m. at your house? They naturally, your dad in bed? Speaker 1 (1:11) Mm-hmm. Okay. They're up and they do their thing, but they're like you. You get up at 5 a.m. So by the time 8 a.m. rolls around, you're like at lunch. Speaker 2 (1:20) I'm like waiting for 8 a.m. to hit to text Courtney. And I have been breaking the rules because I'm like, this is important stuff. I've already lived two lives before 8 a.m. I will say, because Charlie's in daycare, he woke up at 7.15 the other morning. This morning, 6.15. Wow, he's exhausted. Anything out of 5 a.m. is so much better. I'll even take a 6.30. So I feel like I'm living right now. I'm getting an extra hour perhaps. They're Speaker 1 (1:52) talking. My dad is playing music. I'm like, this is wild, you guys. I'm just not used to the chaos of having people. Right. We're watching Dancing with the Stars last night. My sister's got the treadmill out so she can get the rest of her steps. I'm like, it is 8.30 p.m. I'm giggling. You guys, we have a special guest for Dancing with the Stars because my dad will be coming. And he had his whiteboard out last night to take notes. And I laughed. I go, oh, my God, am I my father's daughter? Because I had the whiteboard for the West and Amanda whiteboard combo. Speaker 2 (2:25) I appreciate him taking this so seriously. He is going to be able to come in, critique. He might have to come week by week. We'll get him set up just for like a Rusty's Corner. I Speaker 1 (2:36) was like, we just all lead such different lives. Personally, Speaker 2 (2:40) I would much rather live your life. I love a lively household. No, it's jarring. It's an adjustment. I will say that. Speaker 1 (2:50) Mary the other day sends me a video of Charlie on the coffee tables. And I'm like, well, what is he doing there? She said, he's building strength. What do you mean? Speaker 2 (2:59) I don't think that's weird at all. Like the coffee table I specifically bought for him. I love this article, coffee table. And it has no corners, so it's safe. This is his toy. Speaker 1 (3:12) Oh, right. I thought you bought it for him so that he wouldn't run into it. I didn't realize it was for a jungle gym as well. But that's the pure chaos in your house. And I love Speaker 2 (3:20) that for you. It's Speaker 1 (3:21) city living, Speaker 2 (3:21) babe. Speaker 1 (3:21) It is city Speaker 2 (3:22) living every day. More shit accumulates in here with these dumb plastic toys. And I just never wanted my home to look like a child lived here. Well, guess what? You can definitely tell a child lived here. Speaker 1 (3:37) Okay, I wanted to mention because we got a DM yesterday from a juror that was like, guys, Le Boyfriend was at Burning Man, but he's only posting it on his close friend's story. I think it's crazy she never posted that he was there with her. And Speaker 2 (3:55) I assumed the whole time that he was filming her and you were like, no, I don't know about that. And then you kind of did convince me a little bit that they... had broken up. I kept on at that. I was like, I don't know about that. I really think he went. But there was no evidence. And we finally got some yesterday. Right. But the fact that it was on close friends Speaker 1 (4:17) and then to the jurors, like, wait, how are you on his close friends? Right. I loved this. I loved getting the inner circle of it all. But I just want to say I will backtrack. When I'm wrong, I will admit to it. I was wrong. I want to take that back. Leigh Boyfriend was there. He was filming. And you know what? Maybe I give props to Bethany in that way because I think she knew that would be a talking point. Speaker 2 (4:39) Oh, so this was all strategic. Speaker 1 (4:42) Yes, because he had posted, he had set up her RV. He had done all these cute little things and he had commented saying like, whose RV do you think we slept in? Obviously not mine. So it sounds like he had space for his stuff, but then set it up. And I have to backtrack and apologize for making a rumor. Speaker 2 (4:59) You did start a rumor. I was kind of biting at it. I took a little nibble, but I didn't swallow it. I did not Speaker 1 (5:07) swallow it. It was a little taste test, okay? Speaker 2 (5:10) But, you know, they've made it to six months. She is so in love with him. She keeps on talking about how he calms her nervous system. And I actually do believe it. Her voice changes when she does talk about him. Speaker 1 (5:23) Everyone deserves to find love. So good for her and Gary. Speaker 1 (5:29) I was like, I think Speaker 2 (5:30) his Speaker 1 (5:30) name is Shane. Speaker 2 (5:32) Name is not Gary. Courtney made that one comment. And you guys, I also have to right my wrongs here today. Courtney did ask me how old I thought Haley was. Haley from New York. And, you know, I did think she was 54. I was wrong. I was off by 15 years. And I do want to apologize for that. It is kind of getting a little bit big on TikTok. Haley has commented on Instagram, and she's funny. She can take the joke. She writes about AARP as well. So I'm going to have to write back, but I love a housewife that can take the heat. I think Haley has been a fantastic addition to the show. I absolutely love watching her, and I'd like to smoke a doobie with her. Speaker 2 (6:23) I think you're 54. Speaker 1 (6:24) And that is dating me. You guys know I'm a seven-year-old trapped in this body. She truly is. She truly is. I don't even think you were being mean about it. I think you were honestly shocked by it. The whole point was to say she is the same age as many of these new housewives on this show, that Lindsay Hubbard could be an easy fit into Roni if need be. Sure. Sure. Speaker 2 (6:48) Also saw Erin did a podcast with Dylan Hafer and it made me feel like she is going to film a scene Speaker 1 (6:57) with Roni, that that has already happened. Lindsay Hubbard, guys. Speaker 2 (7:01) Yes. Erin had like a little glimmer in her eye Speaker 1 (7:04) when Dylan was speaking of it. So there's Speaker 2 (7:08) something there. Speaker 1 (7:08) She was smirking for sure. I talk to Lindsay every day. You really got to put her in that graduate program though at Lindsay Hubbard U because Speaker 2 (7:16) Erin needs Speaker 1 (7:17) it. That is true. Yes. Also, we will do the Roni taglines when we talk about Roni next week. A taco? That's so Emily Simpson. Like, does she have a taco business? Anyways, that's for another week. But just wanted to mention, we did see it. We did record before they came out. Yes. And I just want to say, I know we're going to do a Dancing with the Stars episode, but you guys, the Dancing with the Stars male episode that premiered, I freaking loved it. I was boarding a plane. I sat down. I sent all 10 Speaker 2 (7:55) votes in for every Speaker 1 (7:56) single man. I have to vote blindly. You guys know I zero out my votes every week. I want to contribute when Alfonso says we have a record breaking number of votes this week. I need to be a part of that. I have a whole conspiracy theory about devoting. And I can't wait to talk to you about it. Okay, well, I'm just going to let you know that I will also be sending in all 10 votes for every single woman. So I will be contributing 160 votes. My friend said, how do you have the time? I said, don't question. I live a household of one, okay? Speaker 2 (8:26) I was actually thinking, Speaker 1 (8:27) I Speaker 2 (8:27) was Speaker 1 (8:27) like, the person next to me on the plane must think I'm a crazy person because I'm like, copy, paste, copy, paste, copy, paste, copy, paste, copy, paste. I wasn't sure if I was going to have Wi-Fi on the plane. I had to sit down right at the moment, send them through. And I was texting my New York friends, you guys better be freaking voting right now. My friend, she sent a text, said, I voted too late. I said, well, I hope your person doesn't get eliminated. It will be completely your fault. Anyways, I can't wait to talk about that. Should we take a break and come back with part one of Next Gen Reunion? Yes. Speaker 2 (8:59) Okay, Court, I want your overall thoughts on this reunion. It's only a two-parter. It felt a little different to me. I don't even know if I could call it a reunion in some Speaker 1 (9:10) ways. They are our children, and it's never been more apparent in this reunion. They just are naive in the sense of what a reunion is, and I think there's something sweet about that. Because it's like they want to have these like housewife-esque moments, but they're not housewives. They're 20-somethings. They're our kids. It felt too like dad was moderating. Of course. He